With the overwhelming presence of both ultra-fabulous Mediterranean Revival Masterpieces and stylistically confused/Mediterranean “inspired” recent developments, it is easy to forget Sarasota’s legacy and potential for the incubation and appreciation of a variety of architectural styles.

We sometimes forget that just 50 years ago, Sarasota was among the nation’s premier generators of modern architecture and new housing types (along with New Canaan, CT and Palm Springs, CA). While we regret that a majority of these Rudolph/Hiss/Lundy/Siebert landmarks are no longer in existence, today, we can be proud to foster contemporary architectural firms such as Halflants+Pichette and Guy Peterson.

French Chateau, Newport, Polynesian, West Indian, Key West and “indigenous” cracker houses and fishing shacks can also be seen dotting our waterfront. Isn’t it a pleasure to have this mix?

One of my favorite juxtapositions of styles is between 643 Mourning Dove Drive (designed by Cliff Scholz and sold by Salkin & Soublis in 2008) and 647 Mourning Dove Drive (a Guy Peterson OFA creation). Both homes are exquisitely designed and constructed. The massing and site organization is very similar; but stylistically, one’s elegance is rooted in traditional detailing and design, and the other in bold, but sensitive modernism. They stand as a harmonious pair, best appreciated by boat. Next time you’re cruising along the Bird Key Bayfront, be sure to admire them.

Just across the Bay, another fabulous pairing of styles are the architectural masterpieces that flank the entrance of Hanson Bayou on the north end of Siesta Key. Overlooking the bright blue waters of Big Pass and Downtown Sarasota, the Clifford Scholz’ island-inspired estate to the east (3410 Flamingo Avenue currently listed with Salkin & Soublis) and the sculptural Carl Abbott landmark to the west serve as excellent examples of the varied styles you’ll see as you quietly boat down the bayou to admire the neighborhood’s exquisite homes.

Posted by:Marcia Salkin